Executive Summary: 7-Eleven is known in the United States as a convenience store chain where customers can grab snacks, drinks and other everyday products on the go. In most parts of the world, it is a no-frills store with little emphasis on decor. But in Indonesia,7-Eleven has been positioned as a trendy spot where young people spend time, surf the Internet and meet friends. This case study of 7-Eleven illustrates how a brand needs to and can benefit from adapting to a local market.
It's one of the hippest places to hang out in Jakarta. And it isn't some trendy new French restaurant in a Dutch-era heritage building. Instead, thousands of people in the Indonesian capital spend their evenings sipping coffee or beer on pavement tables at their neighbourhood 7-Eleven, the international convenience store synonymous with anytime, on-the-go shopping in most parts of the world.
Indonesia's 7-Elevens are, clearly, a long way from the original concept behind the world's largest convenience store chain. "At 7-Eleven, our purpose and mission is to make life a little easier for our guests by being where they need us, whenever they need us," says the company's website. And that's what it has been doing all over the world since the first convenience store was born after a Southland Ice Co employee in Dallas started selling milk, eggs and bread from an ice dock in 1927.
The 7-Eleven chain has about 49,500 stores in 16 countries across the world, over 10,000 of them in North AmericaToday, the chain has grown to about 49,500 stores in 16 countries, more than 10,000 in North America itself, but its core customer remains the same: people on the go who need a one-stop shop to quickly buy everyday products. Typically, most 7-Eleven stores all over the world are conveniently located in office areas and are open around the clock.
Initially, 7-Eleven spread its wings slowly. In its early years, it grew strategically in suburbs in the United States and areas too small for a supermarket: by 1963, it had 1,000 stores across the country. But it began to grow at breakneck pace after it adopted a franchisee model the following year. In 1969, 7-Eleven began expanding beyond US borders and set up shop in Canada. In the 1970s and early 1980s, it expanded to Mexico, Japan and Asian markets such as Taiwan, Singapore and the Philippines. With the increasing importance of emerging Asian markets such as Thailand, the Philippines and Malaysia, 7-Eleven Corporation moved its corporate headquarters to Japan in 2001.
Traditionally, 7-Eleven's entry strategy is to target urban markets and tailor stores to local tastes. For example, customers in Hong Kong can pay their phone and utility bills at a local 7-Eleven; in Taiwan, they can service their bicycles or photocopy at the convenience store; and in the US they can pick-up their online Amazon shopping there. By offering these services - often exclusively - customer traffic can be increased significantly. To achieve this customer orientation and competitive advantage, almost all stores arfe operated by franchisees, who understand the local environment.
7-Eleven in Indonesia has everything local markets offer, and more. It also has live entertainment and wireless connectivity
But Indonesia had some typical traits not found in other markets. For one, just hanging out and doing nothing is so deeply embedded in Indonesian culture, the local language has a special word for it: nongkrong.
People traditionally gather at street markets and share stories, eat in local markets and roadside food stalls called warungs or Western fastfood chains such as McDonalds, Dunking Donuts or coffee shops such as Starbucks which entered Southeast Asia a whi le ago.
Moreover, Indonesia is highly plugged-in: the country had an estimated 20 to 30 million Internet users in 2009, a big chunk of them between the ages of 15 and 19. 7-Eleven studied the culture, habits and tastes of the Indonesian population and realised Indonesia lacked places where young people could hang out, eat, drink and follow their new passion: being online. It adopted a unique business model in the country: it blended a small supermarket with inexpensive readymade food and seating to cater to Jakarta customers looking for outdoor recreation space in a city where traffic jams often restrict mobility.
7-Eleven in Indonesia included everything local markets and street vendors offered - and more. The store is open 24 hours, has hasslefree parking, offers leisure activities such as concerts, is air-conditioned and, most importantly, has wireless connectivity. Sixty-five per cent of the Indonesian franchise's customers are less than 30 years old and love social networking. 7-Eleven also featured local artists or live bands to further attract the nongkrong-ing crowds at its stores.
The target customers
When it came to pricing strategy, the local franchise followed the company's traditional model. It leveraged the fact that its stores are open 24/7, even when other food retail competitors are closed, and priced products at the upper end.
The placement strategy of 7-Eleven Indonesia was also the same as the US. The stores are located in commercial and office areas, but not public transport stations because they are not seen as premium locations.
But unlike the US, the archipelago of around 17,000 islands does not have a 7-Eleven literally at every corner; instead it focuses on big hubs in Indonesia.
7-Eleven Indonesia's unique customer experience extends to popular local artists and social media websites. Local artists perform in 7-Eleven stores because their fans like to hang out in these areas and 7-Eleven provides the location at low or no costs. Although 7-Eleven has a first mover advantage and has already built up a strong brand name and large customer base, new competitors will come into this market and existing ones are likely to reposition themselves. 7-Eleven should continue to innovate its product range and offer additional services that meet local traditions and customer needs to stay ahead of the competition.
How much to adapt is a classic dilemma for global brands
Retail is one area, especially mass merchandise retail, where global success stories are few and far between: Prof Nirmalya Kumar
As global brands from Western countries adapt to emerging markets, they face the challenge of different demographics and income patterns. How much to adapt while retaining the brand DNA is a classic dilemma. Adaptation needs to be limited for luxury brands as their target market tends to be the top of the pyramid, where consumption patterns are global.
Similarly, for technological products, like software or smartphones, the adaptation needed is relatively small. Retail is one area, especially mass merchandise retail, where global success stories are few and far between. Even the most successful global retailers - Carrefour, Metro and Wal-Mart - have had their share of failures.
Why is global mass retailing so challenging? The products/brands sold by mass retailers are not unique - and are already widely available in the country. As a later entrant, a global retailer is unlikely to find the best locations available and it is unlikely to have a lower cost of operations than local mom-and-pop stores. To succeed, the global retailer has to offer better customer experience while hoping that savings from state-of-the-art global systems will more than compensate for the higher real estate and operating cost disadvantages.
The 7-Eleven case in Indonesia is an outstanding example of a global retailer having found a unique proposition with its customer experience that taps directly into the demographic differences of the country. For global firms, after China and India, Indonesia has perhaps the greatest potential. Kudos to 7-Eleven for unlocking this.
Prof Nirmalya Kumar, Professor of Marketing and Director of the Aditya Birla India Centre at London Business School
7-Eleven Stands Out For Its Marketing Strategy
It shifted its core brand proposition from a convenience store in the US to a place where convenience store meets Internet cafe: Lassi Lastiani
7-Eleven's success in Indonesia is an ideal case to study how a brand redefines its marketing strategy to enter a new market. While other brands are struggling to find their place in the market, 7-Eleven stands out for its marketing strategy. The new local strategy is aligned to the growing demographic opportunity in the Indonesian market, where young people below 30 account for almost 40 per cent of the population. Capturing this important market with the right positioning - a cool, trendy place to hang out with affordable meals, drinks and fast Internet - have been the key success factors. It shifted its core brand proposition from a convenience store in the US to a place where convenience store meets Internet cafe for young people in Indonesia.
Moving forward, keeping pace with changing customer needs, a fast-moving economy and a competitive environment in Indonesia are the challenges for 7-Eleven. While the entry strategy perfectly captured a strategic position, competitors are adapting their strategy to win back market share. The local 7-Eleven concept is not that hard to copy after all, especially when some competitors have been established in the country for a longer period of time. The size and design of 7-Eleven stores needed to implement its strategy also deters expansion in every corner of the country. It has to carefully chose the right corner to be spacious enough for both the store and Internet cafe, and strategically located to be viable as a 24/7 concept.
Lassi Lastiani, Finance Director, Consolidated Services International, Jakarta
*An earlier version of the case study misspelt the first author's name.
(This case study is from the Aditya Birla India Centre of London Business School.)
What can we learn from 7-Eleven's experiences in Indonesia? Write to firstname.lastname@example.org or post your comments at www. businesstoday.in/casestudy-7-Eleven. Your views will be published in our online edition. The best response will win a copy of India Inside by Nirmalya Kumar and Phanish Puranam. Previous case studies are at www.businesstoday.in/casestudy
Katie Danielson IBLAS Dr. Pahl 6 November, 2015 Case Study 3: 7-Eleven in Taiwan: Adaptation of Convenience Stores to New Markets There are many economic and business characteristics of the convenience store industry in Taiwan. Taiwan’s economy has become both a democracy and a capitalist economy over the last half century. As well as, Taiwan is considered to be one of Asia’s economic tigers. Traditionally, Taiwan’s GDP had been 70 percent of growth and came from exports, specifically from electronics and machinery. As well as, for a long period of time, the inflation rate, in Taiwan, were low, causing high growth rates due to the liberalization of the economy by the Taiwanese government. The low overall inflation rate was also caused by food prices contributing to a large proportion of the consumer price index basket and the international and domestic trends in food prices. Additionally, there are many business characteristics of the convenience store industry in Taiwan. Demographically, Taiwan’s high population density created the growth and proper business environment for the convenience store industry. Geographically, the zoning permits, in Taiwan, are vertical, characterized by individual high-rise building, which also is a unique characteristic of the convenience store industry in Taiwan because there is an increase amount of foot traffic and more customers going to convenience stores. As well as, consumers in Taiwan have an obsession with immediacy and convenience store filled this gap. Convenience stores business entry strategy is franchising, which has become a very important draw to Taiwanese entrepreneurs because it allowed them the freedom to manage their own store. Taiwanese store